Saturday, December 23, 2006

Whoever said...

you can't go home again was probably related to my mother.

It's been a very trying and disappointing week. I think I have finally come to the conclusion that, no, my mother and I cannot be friends. We can't be mother and daughter. We aren't even very good at being civil.

I think it is time to say goodbye.

It's never easy to realize that you and your parent aren't cut from the same cloth. My mother and I are not only cut from the same cloth, but we can't even share the same cloth.

"You have to understand the way we were raised," she says to me during a conversation about why she is so selfish. "Your Uncle and I were both raised by people who believed the sun rose and set on their asses. That is why we are the way we are."

"Copout," says CP. "I was raised by someone who was that same way, and I don't believe the sun sets on my ass. I may think the sun SHOULD, but I know it doesn't."

"You know," she says with utter disdain, "you are definately your fathers daughter."

"Thank GOD," I snap back with equal bitterness. "He hated you. Now I know why."

And it's sad, so sad, that a mother and daughter, two women ages 65 and 40 respectively, cannot find some common ground to stand on together.

Earlier this morning, I was picking up my nephews. My mother was getting ready for her Friday beauty parlor appointment.

"I don't want ANY children in this house today while I am getting ready," she barks at me.

"Um, those children to which you refer. Those are your GRANDCHILDREN, correct?"

"Look sister," she says to me, like I am some stranger in the street who stole her parking spot, "if you don't like the rules, there's always a hotel."

"Wow, what a kind thing to say to someone who traveled TWELVE HUNDRED miles to be with you for the holidays."

"Hey," she said flippantly, "I didn't ask you to come."

You know what?

She didn't. She's right.

I was under the impression that my mother would welcome having her daughter, son in law, grandson, grandaughter and her new husband, all under one roof. I know I would relish that, if I were her. I love having my niece and nephews around me. The more children in my home, the better. It's what makes the house a home. A home is nothing more than a skeleton, a piece of framework, until the family living in it gives it the heartbeat.

I won't stop coming to New York. It's my homestate, but apparently, not my home.

Not anymore.

But, it is where my husband proposed to me. It is where both of my children were conceived. It is where I met my childhood best friend who is still my best friend to this day. It is where my precious niece and nephews are. It is where I grew up, got my first kiss, wrote my first poem, laughed my first laugh.

It is not, however, where I will shed my last tear.

More than likely, that honor will be given to Florida, my new home. Undoubtably, Esther will be the cause. Without uncertainty, I will allow her under my skin again in approximately four months from now, when the memory of this trip starts to fade. I will miss her. I will call her. I will reach out for a mother. She will let me into her fold long enough to hurt me once again.

"I'll NEVER go there again," I will scream at my husband. He, in turn, will nod his head.

"You don't have to, baby," he will say and in the back of his mind, know that he will be making travel arrangements soon enough. He won't make fun of my decision. Instead, he will feel sorry for me, for being caught in this web...in this vicious cycle.

I wish I had some humorous anecdote about Esther this trip. I don't. Her cruelty and abuse have risen to an all time high.

She walked in here earlier while I was on the computer and kissed my cheek.

"This has been such a wonderful visit," she gushed.

"Really?"

"Absolutely," she replied. "The best one yet."

She left the room.

Apparently, she measures the delight of our visits in my tears. I cried a lot this visit. She ruined a lot of days for me, including my anniversary by not even acknowledging it.

"YOU didn't remember MINE," she said. "And MINE was a 25th anniversary! Much more important than a FOURTH."

"I sent you flowers, threw you a party and flew the whole family in for it," I said quietly.

"YOU didn't do that," she countered. "Your UNCLE did that."

I looked at my husband, mouth agape, eyes bulging. I couldn't even speak.

"Um, no Esther," my husband said, "it was your DAUGHTER who set everything up. Your brother only took care of the New York details because she wasn't there to do it. She invited everyone. She set the whole thing up from Florida."

Esther shrugs.

"Well, I didn't know that," she said.

I sighed. I went up to my room. I cried.

This trip has been a disaster for me. Truth be known, I wish I could turn back time and be in Hawaii right now, like my husband originally wanted. Next year, I listen to him.

Alright. I probably won't. But please, next year at this time? Remind me of this vacation and refer me back to this post.

Consider it a large step in the preservation of my mental health.

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

oh CP....I wish my arms could reach U from AZ.......It is obvious that E is hurting for SOME reason.....that she will NEVER reveal...my mother is like that......word games....cat and mouse chase til she feels its time to share what is going on ......by this time the drama has the spotlight arranged JUST SO........

:::& SCENE!::: takes bow...exits stage left.....

rise above it....tell her U are sorry she is not able to reach out to U ....and then calmly tell her the new boundaries.....so when it gets twisted later when you are trying your best to enforce them ( its hard...I speak from experience)....there are no surprises or opportunities for her to twist it further........

once again....I am sooosorry for your pain............& after reading the ch's re your ex......U know I have connections ..when ever U need me .......MUAH!

Anonymous said...

OMG! I am sorry you had such a crappy time! And I guess your Mom is living in a totally different universe calling this the best visit yet...

I am sorry you feel so bad, CP. I wish I could change things for you!

Many many many Dutchysmooches, hugz and kisses from over here! Mwah!

There are MANY people who love you for who you are: a wonderful person and a cool hot chick in all!

JavaJabber said...

You just wrote about my feelings when I visited my mother in October. I'm still reeling from that. She has 7 children who mostly live as far away from her as possible.

I keep asking myself how ... knowing how I am as a mother ... my own mother could be so cold and hurtful. I still don't have the answer and I may never know.

But I think I have finally gotten to the point where I actually feel sorry for her. She's alone. Truly alone. And she has no one to blame but herself.

I'm sorry you had to go through this. It's not easy feeling rejected as a person, it's so much more difficult when it's your mother doing the rejecting.

I hope you have a safe trip home and that you remember that you are truly a good person and deserve so much more.

Anonymous said...

You know what, CP? You just described my own selfish Mother. I don't know the history between the two of you. But your post struck a cord so deep --- soo soo deep in me. My relationship with my mother is tentative at best. Fucking miserable at it's worst.

The only difference between you and me, is that I no longer crave her specific 'mothering'. My mother is also around the same age as yours (me being 42 - near your age). I realised a couple of years ago that my mother would NEVER ever ever ever give me what I NEEDED; nurturing support. Not ever. Once I realised that, I stopped expecting it. It made me sit back and totally re-evaluate just what this 'relationship' was, wasn't and could possibly be. I've come to the conclusion (yes, conclusion) that 'she' will never be my mother other than in the biological sense of the word. She will never appreciate the gift of her two daughters who craved (on such a primal level) her love and affection. This isn't to say there haven't been moments (mere moments only, though!) of affection -- but the cruelty, abuse and betrayal has far outweighed those moments. So, I step back now -- and I see her for what she is; a lonely, pathetic woman who is purely incapable of sympathy, empathy and simply will not (cannot?) take responsibility for her choices in life. To do so would probably mean she'd die of guilt. So, I accept now that probably all I'll ever get from her in terms of 'mothering' are those rare moments of affection. I expect nothing more. And it hurts a lot less now.

The thing that I most struggle with now is my own relationship with my daughter. It sounds like you've managed to develop a healthy one with yours -- I only wish, pray and hope I can develop one with mine.

I read some advice you left on someone elses blog about what she might tell her children later (I can't remember the blog unfortunately:( ) - and it also struck a cord in me; to be very very careful what I tell my daughter about her biological father (to leave out things that would only hurt her and make her doubt having been wanted).

Anyway, I'm so glad I found your blog. I don't know you and you don't know me, but wow, I think if we met, we'd get on like bread and butter - and I could learn a lot from you.

Blessings this holiday. Go away from this trip and KNOW that there is nothing wrong with you. There is something vital missing in your mother's capacity to love. And how sad is that for her. It sounds like you've 'planted a lovely garden' in spite of the shit-heap handed down to you.

Lots of love!
(sorry this is so long!!)

Anonymous said...

Oh, CP! {{{{{{{{{{many hugs}}}}}}}}}}

Mr. Fabulous said...

I'm sorry hon. We like it better when you're here in Florida anyway :)

Denise said...

Some women are not cut out to be mothers. She also sounds very immature for a 65 year old woman. What a shame.

Yeah...next year think about Hawaii.

Anna said...

First of all, let me say thank you for being so generous with your comforting words; they have helped more than you could ever know.

Now, let me find the words to comfort you...

I'm here, I can relate (Esther is so much like my own monster it's scary), and I care.

And even when you don't want to be, you are right about this.

LOVE

Anonymous said...

Oh, CP,
How awful. :( Next year, you should come with me to visit my family in New Mexico. It ain't New York, but we do have a family that just OOZES love and laughter. My mother, in stereotypical Italian fashion, would welcome you guys with about a billion hugs, and would feed you until you nearly burst. Although we're Catholic, my mother could whip up a stellar Hanukkah feast (any excuse to cook is a good one in her book). And besides, if you came over for the holidays, she would focus on catering to you guys instead of harping on me for being her ONLY CHILD WITHOUT A HUSBAND AND KIDS. So yeah, CP, please come, umkay? :)

Anonymous said...

the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over, expecting different results!!!! girl, get the fuck over it and go to hawaii NOW!!!! i haven't spoken to my mother in 2 years and have added about 10 years to my life!!!! it was better for me than quitting smoking!!!

Tense Teacher said...

What is it about our mothers that turn intelligent, otherwise confident women into complete and utter fools? I am the same way about my mom. I know that she is childish and makes me insane (she is the reason for my spending the entire summer in therapy), and yet I HAVE TO talk to her and seek her approval, so I know exactly where you're coming from with this post.

Hang in there.

Last Girl On Earth said...

Aw CP, I'm so sorry your trip didn't turn out as you planned it. It's so hard for me to comment about your mother as I am missing mine so much right now it hurts beyond belief. But to you, my friend, I offer virtual hugs. And net year, shorten that trip and go to Hawaii. (The most wonderful place on the planet!)

Linda said...

CP - I feel your pain. I wish that things could be better for you. I really do. You have suffered so much for someone your age (I'm 40 too, so I know where you stand). I think that it's so hard to let go, because you are forever hopeful that things will be better the next time.

I hated my mother...hell, most of my family for a LONG time. When I finally came to realization that they were the way they were, I found it easier to be around them. I've learned to ignore all the side comments and snide remarks. But then again, I'm always so far away that it's hard for me to see them often. It makes it easier to cherish the visits, even when I'm exasperated to the end.

I pray that some day, your mom sees how she hurts you. But you always have us!

geek said...

And the hits keep comeing. I can only say Tense and I love you.

Anonymous said...

You keep letting her back into your life because you are NOT the selfish, totally self absorbed person she is. You are a better mother, and it hurts you that she rejects her grandchildren.

My sister and I never realized how truly selfish our own mother could be until we became parents. Then suddenly it clicked, our childhood was not quite right. After an exasperating visit with mom (which is every visit), my sister will turn to me and just sigh, "she'll never change - why do I keep doing this to myself?"

Enjoy the rest of your hometown. She is only one, albeit an integral, person there.

ginviren said...

CP - sorry to hear about this. I agree with Tense Teacher about mothers turning otherwise rational intelligent women into fools. It sucks.

J. said...

Okay, so I posted yesterday that I wanted to come back in my next life as a jewish mom.
But I was most definitely thinking of YOU and not Esther.
Hugs babe. That sucks.

ablondeblogger said...

CP, I am so, so sorry. :( You're right.....it doesn't sound like it's healthy to be around her. That is emotional abuse and you shouldn't have to put up with it. Maybe, just maybe, if you take a stand and tell her why you want her out of your life, she'll change her ways? Or maybe not. I'm praying she will.

I cut my father out of my life and there are so many days where I wish I had a "real" father. I consider my stepfather to be my father now and call him dad, and he considers me his daughter. I'm very blessed in that respect, but it still saddens me that my real father is a whack job.

I wish I were older than you so I could adopt you, take you in and treat you the way you deserve to be treated.

I hope you don't go crawling back to her, even when it hurts. You had the courage to leave an abusive husband....you have to take that same stand with your mother and stick to it, even if it hurts. You, your husband, and your children all deserve better.

She must be really psycho to not realize what a treasure she has in you as a daughter. She is so blessed and just shits all over that. That pisses me off. :(

(((((HUGS))))))

Anonymous said...

I'm so sorry you had to go through this.

Kisses.

J R Estelle said...

your week sounds like mine - and your husband is a GREAT guy, seriously. Now...you know any women with those qualities?

Happy Holidays, CP

It's Me, Maven... said...

I have no words.

Only empathy and one question.

If the visits are so devoid of enjoyment, why bother? Trust me when I say, it's far easier to expend zero energy (by not planning trips, by not putting one's self out) towards a parent who is against you.

Trust me, cutting her off isn't as hard as you think it is.

It's scary how easy it is.
It's scary how liberating it is.

ramblin' rose said...

Hugz CP !! I too like many of your readers have a mom from hell!! I had to move Continents and totally cut her off from my life. At times I grieve terribly for a mother and for feelings of being wanted.....

Cutting her off was the best thing to do in my case and was and is very hard.. It took lots of therapy for greater understanding....

I often wonder what happend in our parents generation to make them such idiots at parenting? Why are they so miserable and so hateful to thier children....

Bent Fabric said...

I'm sorry, CP. :( I can relate. My mother and I have severed all ties. I visited the Bronx a couple of weeks ago. Even walked by her building. However, I knew better than to try to make contact.

Things may be much harder on you though because of the kids. There is just no easy way around it is there?! I have no wise words for you, but I can send you a HUGE hug!

Avitable said...

While my situation is not that bad, I can sympathize. And next year, I won't say I told you so, because you still have to keep doing it. I understand that.

Anonymous said...

Esther and my MIL would get along great! Even when they hurt us, it is hard to break those family ties, isn't it?

 

Blog Design by twoscoopz{design}